A debate about Joe the Plumber

Related rulings:

"And 100 percent, John, of your ads . . . 100 percent of them have been negative."  

Barack Obama, Wednesday, October 15th, 2008.

Ruling: Pants on Fire! | Details

"He voted twice for a budget resolution that increases the taxes on individuals making $42,000 a year."

John McCain, Wednesday, October 15th, 2008.

Ruling: Half-True | Details

If you're a small business and don't "adopt the health care plan that Senator Obama mandates, he's going to fine you."

John McCain, Wednesday, October 15th, 2008.

Ruling: False | Details

Under John McCain's health care plan, people get a $5,000 tax credit to buy a $12,000 health care policy, and "that's a loss for you."

Barack Obama, Wednesday, October 15th, 2008.

Ruling: False | Details

"Obama said he would unilaterally renegotiate the North American Free Trade Agreement."

John McCain, Wednesday, October 15th, 2008.

Ruling: Mostly True | Details

"Congressman John Lewis, an American hero, made allegations that Sarah Palin and I were somehow associated with ... the worst chapter in American history. ... And, Senator Obama, you didn't repudiate those remarks."

John McCain, Wednesday, October 15th, 2008.

Ruling: True | Details

Bookmark this story:

SUMMARY: In their final debate, Barack Obama and John McCain spar about whose policies would be better for Joe Wurzelbacher, an Ohio plumber. We find mistakes by both candidates.

The star of the third and final presidential debate was a plumber from Ohio named Joe Wurzelbacher. Joe, referred to several times as "Joe the Plumber," became the debate's Everyman as the candidates sparred over whether he would win or lose from their tax and health care policies.

We took a look at one of the Joe claims and several others:

• McCain invoked Joe in his claim that small businesses would have to pay fines under Obama's health care plan. We gave that one a False.

• Obama was way off with his claim that 100 percent of McCain's campaign ads have been negative. Obama was so far off that he earned a Pants on Fire.

• McCain inched a little closer to the truth with the latest version of his claim about Obama's vote on a Democratic budget resolution and its impact on people earning more than $42,000. We gave McCain a Half True.

• Obama distorted the numbers about the cost of McCain's health care plan and earned a False.

• We found McCain was accurately summarizing Obama's position on the North American Free Trade Agreement. We rated McCain's claim Mostly True.

• And, lastly, we found McCain was correct to say that Obama "didn’t repudiate" remarks made by Rep. John Lewis, that McCain and Sarah Palin "were somehow associated with ... the worst chapter in American history." Obama released a statement, but never specifically criticized Lewis. This one is True.