Texas Republican Senate candidate Ken Paxton voted “to protect puppy abusers.”
The facts behind Talarico’s ‘Scanduel’ ad saying Texas AG Ken Paxton sided with puppy abusers
If your time is short
- In 2011 as a state representative, Ken Paxton voted against a Texas bill that increased bond fees for people whose animals were taken away after a court found they had treated them cruelly.
- The bill made it more costly for people who a court found had abused animals to appeal that finding, but it did not change the penalties for animal abuse.
- Paxton did not explain his no vote. Others who voiced opposition at the time said it was a question of procedural fairness: Additional bond fees were generally not required for other civil cases.
The candidates for U.S. Senate in Texas have let some nasty accusations fly this campaign season, and now Democrat James Talarico is up with a new ad accusing Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton of protecting puppy abusers.
Talarico’s campaign released an ad on Oct. 6 that parodies sports betting apps promotions, encouraging viewers to bet on “Scanduel” about various Paxton “scandals.” The ad says onscreen, “The app isn’t real, but Ken Paxton’s scandals are.”
Among the bets the ad says viewers can win on: “Ken Paxton voting to protect puppy abusers.”
NEW AD: Introducing SCANDUEL!
The only betting app where you can parlay Ken Paxton’s scandals — and get paid!
Here’s a tip: Always bet that he did the thing. 💰 https://t.co/Hir2F2UALC
— Team Talarico (@TeamTalaricoHQ) October 6, 2026
The ad also mentions the 2026 plea deal Paxton’s office struck with a man accused of child sexual abuse and a 2022 incident in which a process server said Paxton evaded a subpoena by fleeing his home in a truck driven by his wife.
With President Donald Trump’s backing, Paxton won May’s primary election against incumbent Republican Sen. John Cornyn. Talarico, a Texas House representative and Presbyterian seminarian, has made Paxton’s corruption allegations a central campaign message. Talarico leads in several recent polls, signaling a closer race than recent Senate contests in the Republican stronghold.
Accusations in 2020 by senior Paxton staff of bribery and abuse of office sparked an FBI investigation and led the Republican-led Texas House to impeach Paxton in 2023. The Republican-led Senate acquitted him.
But what about the puppies? There’s a real vote behind the claim, but it’s not as extreme as the ad’s wording suggests.
Paxton’s vote on animal abuse law
Talarico’s campaign pointed PolitiFact to a 2011 vote Paxton took as a state legislator. Paxton voted against a Texas bill that increased bond fees for people whose animals were taken away after a court found they had treated them cruelly. The law defined cruel treatment as torture, serious overwork, unreasonable abandonment or depriving them of food, care or shelter.
Paxton was one of 15 people in the 150-member Texas House of Representatives to oppose the bill.
Before the 2011 law, if a civil court ruled a person had abused an animal, the court removed the animal and placed it in a shelter. A person who wanted to appeal the ruling had to post a bond to cover the estimated cost of caring for the animal during the appeal process. A judicial bond is a financial guarantee to ensure a person can cover court fees if the appeal fails, and it is refunded if the appeal is successful.
The 2011 measure increased the bond amount for someone appealing to include both the animal care cost and the original court costs. The bill also said a court couldn’t impose a bond amount higher than that combined cost.
But even if the bill had failed, the penalties for court-determined animal abusers would have been the same if they lost the appeal or didn’t appeal: They’d still have to pay both the court costs and the animal-care costs, which was always the case.
The bill’s opponents said it would make the appeal process too costly for people who want to appeal the ruling. They also said the additional bond fees were generally not required for other civil cases. The bill’s sponsor said the bond rules would ensure counties got reimbursed for court costs and keeping the animals if the government won the appeal.
Paxton’s campaign did not respond to a request for comment, and he did not explain his vote at the time.
Animal research at Texas A&M
Talarico’s campaign pointed PolitiFact to an attorney general opinion — not a vote — involving Texas A&M University. In an Aug. 21 interview with MS NOW, Talarico said he held an event with the Austin Humane Society to show that Paxton is “anti-puppy.” Talarico pointed to Paxton’s office’s decision to side with Texas A&M against releasing records about their research on dogs and cats in the university’s research labs.
In 2015, an animal welfare group called Beagle Freedom Project used state public information laws to request records from Texas A&M University about the conditions, treatment and veterinary care the school was providing for research animals. Texas A&M argued it could keep the records private because they contained commercially valuable information and privileged veterinary records.
Paxton’s office sided with the university against making the records public.
Texas A&M’s research involved breeding dogs with muscular dystrophy to research treatment for the disease in humans. The university said the research was necessary and the dogs received frequent veterinary care, and the lab had never been cited for animal-welfare violations. The university stopped breeding dogs for the program in 2019.
Separately, Paxton’s office recently started an animal welfare investigation into a Texas puppy mill. A July press release from Paxton’s office said records showed some of Lone Star Pups’ puppies were receiving pre-sale veterinary exams in Holmes County, Ohio, an area the press release described as “widely known for large-scale, and in some cases unethical, commercial dog breeding operations.”
Our ruling
An ad from Talarico’s campaign said Paxton voted “to protect puppy abusers.”
As a state lawmaker in 2011, Paxton was among 15 people to vote against a successful bill to impose higher bond fees on people appealing a court ruling that they had abused an animal.
The bill made the appeals process more cumbersome and more expensive for people the court said abused animals. But it didn’t increase penalties for animal abuse itself, and it did not change the fact that abusers still had to pay for an animal’s care.
Even though Paxton didn’t explain his rationale behind his no vote, others who voiced opposition at the time said it was a question of procedural fairness.
The statement contains an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression. We rate it Mostly False.
Our Sources
Text exchange with James Talarico campaign, Oct. 11, 2026
James Talarico campaign, X post, Oct. 6, 2026
PolitiFact, Fact-checking James Talarico’s attack on Texas AG Ken Paxton about sex abuse plea deal, June 3, 2026
The Texas Tribune, Ken Paxton tried to avoid being served with subpoena, court record says, Sept. 26, 2022
PBS News, Ken Paxton has survived years of scandals. Can James Talarico change that?, July 27, 2026
The New York Times, Texas U.S. Senate Election Polls 2026, accessed Oct. 10, 2026
The Texas Tribune,Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton acquitted on all 16 articles of impeachment, Sept. 16, 2023
AP News, AP Sources: FBI is investigating Texas attorney general, Nov. 17, 2020
AP News, Justice Department declined to prosecute Texas AG Paxton in final weeks of Biden’s term: AP sources, April 3, 2025
House Research Organization, Texas House of Representatives, Daily Floor Report, Part Two, May 10, 2011
Texas House of Representatives, House Journal, 82nd Legislature, Regular Session, 76th Day, May 13, 2011
Texas Legislature, HB 963 – Enrolled version – Bill Text, accessed Oct. 10, 2026
The Texas Tribune, Texas House Transcript, May 12, 2011, accessed Oct. 10, 2026
Office of the Attorney General of Texas, Open Records Letter Ruling OR2015-12015, June 17, 2015
Office of the Attorney General of Texas, Open Records Letter No. 2015-13076, June 30, 2015
Office of the Attorney General of Texas, Open Records Letter No. 2015-13077, June 30, 2015
Houston Press, A&M Sued Over Research Animal Vet Records, accessed Oct. 10, 2026
Texas A&M College of Veterinary Medicine & Biomedical Sciences, Information about Duchenne muscular dystrophy research at Texas A&M, accessed Oct. 10, 2026
KBTX, Texas A&M to end breeding of sick dogs in its medical research, Sep. 12, 2019
Texas Attorney General, Attorney General Ken Paxton Investigates Puppy Mill to Ensure Puppies Being Sold in Texas Receive Top-Tier Veterinary Care as Advertised, accessed Oct. 10, 2026