Says Donald Trump "has the second-highest disapproval ratings of anyone running for president."
Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Ted Cruz incorrectly says Donald Trump has 'second-highest disapproval' of any presidential hopeful
A dozen days before suspending his presidential candidacy, Sen. Ted Cruz charged Donald Trump with being the second-most disliked candidate for president, implying that only Hillary Clinton was worse off.
The Texan's claim emerged in an online ad, "War Room," which was posted as Cruz scrambled unsuccessfully to best Trump in Kentucky’s April 2016 Republican presidential primary.
The shadowy video purports to show the actress portraying Clinton huddling with nervous advisers who say first that Trump has considerable weaknesses. "He has the second-highest disapproval ratings of anyone running for president," an adviser says. Next, another pretend aide asks who has the highest (or worst) disapproval rating--and all eyes fall away.
Of late, Trump and Clinton appear to be poised for a November showdown in the general election, representing the Republican and Democratic parties, respectively. It’s also so that fresh polls including an ABC News/Washington Post poll taken in mid-May 2016 suggest each hopeful has high unfavorability ratings--giving the two unwelcome common ground.
Regardless, we checked Cruz’s poll claim in part because whenever candidates tout polls, there’s a risk of obfuscation and oversimplification. For instance, this April we rated False Trump’s claim that his favorability numbers were higher than Ronald Reagan’s at the same time in 1980. Also in April, we rated Mostly False Cruz’s claim that "poll after poll" showed him beating Clinton one-on-one.
So for recent history’s sake, we decided to see if Cruz was right pre-departure about Trump having the second-highest disapproval ratings among all presidential hopefuls.
Cruz’s data
In response to our query, Cruz campaign spokeswoman Catherine Frazier emailed data from a national poll released Feb. 18, 2016, by respected pollster Quinnipiac University, naming Clinton and Trump the least-favored candidates, respectively.
The questionnaire asked 1,342 registered voters intended to represent the national electorate between February 10 and 15, 2016, whether their opinions of 11 candidates and politicians were favorable, unfavorable,or if they lacked the information to judge. Fifty-eight percent registered as "unfavorable" to Clinton, 57 percent said as much for Trump.
Then again, the poll’s 2.7 percentage point margin of error means that Clinton’s lead on Trump for unfavorability was too close to call.
We looked into other voter polls, finding -- in contrast to Cruz’s claim -- Trump uniformly viewed as the least liked candidate, counting Clinton and others still vying at the time of the respective polls.
But first we heard back from Tim Malloy, assistant director of Quinnipiac Polls, who said in a phone interview that it’s "apples and oranges" to mix up polls that gauge voter impressions of candidates with those that check on whether they approve or disapprove of someone’s job performance.
Favorability, Malloy said, rates people’s overall impression of candidates, including their character and personality. "It’s pretty much, ‘Do you like the person?’" he said.
Approval ratings tie to how well people think someone has done a job. For example, Malloy said, at the end of New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani’s years in that office, Giuliani had low favorability and high approval. People didn’t much like him, Malloy said, yet they thought he did a good job as mayor.
Other data
Now let’s turn to what other polls showed per the frontrunners’ favorable/unfavorable ratings at the time Cruz was still a candidate.
Up to the debut of Cruz’s ad, the political poll aggregator RealClearPolitics had posted 59 polls rating Trump’s favorability, starting from a Quinnipiac poll taken in May 2015, weeks before he announced his candidacy. It had posted more than 200 polls rating Clinton’s favorability, starting from a Rasmussen poll taken in November 2012.
As of May 25, 2016, the website’s aggregation of polls gave Clinton a net 56.3 percent unfavorable rating; Trump had a net 58 percent unfavorable rating.
But that didn’t nail down the two candidates’ scores at the time Cruz aired his ad.
For our part, we pulled the relevant results from 21 polls rating candidate favorability and listed by RealClearPolitics between the Feb. 18, 2016 publication of the Quinnipiac poll shared by the Cruz campaign and the April 21, 2016, debut of Cruz’s ad, also folding in the poll immediately before the Feb. 18 poll.
Some of the 22 polls contacted registered voters while others surveyed likely voters. In each one, Trump had the highest disapproval ratings among candidates of either party; Clinton ran second to Trump in unfavorability in 18 polls.
Presidential Candidates With Top Unfavorable Poll Ratings, February-April 2016
Poll
Conducted (2016)
Number polled
Highest unfavorable rating
Second-highest unfavorable rating
Feb 2 - 3
1,236
Trump - 63 percent
Bush - 54 percent
Feb 10 - 15
1,342
Clinton - 58 percent
Trump - 57 percent
Feb 11 - 15
1,033
Trump - 58 percent
Clinton - 51 percent
Feb 14 - 16
800
Trump - 59 percent
Clinton - 50 percent
Feb 24 - 27
2,000
Trump - 59 percent
Bush - 57 percent
Feb 24 - 27
920
Trump - 60 percent
Clinton - 55 percent
Feb 26 - March 3
Trump - 63 percent
Clinton - 53 percent
March 3-6
1,000
Trump - 67 percent
Clinton - 52 percent
Featured Fact-check
March 10 - 12
2,000
Trump - 61 percent
Clinton - 54 percent
March 17-20
1,008
Trump - 60 percent
Clinton - 51 percent
March 17-20
925
Trump - 67 percent
Clinton - 56 percent
March 17-20
1,058
Trump - 57 percent
Clinton - 52 percent
March 19-22
1,451
Trump - 61 percent
Clinton - 56 percent
March 19-22
1,000
Trump - 68 percent
Clinton - 53 percent
March 20 - 22
1,016
Trump - 65 percent
Clinton - 58 percent
March 24 - 26
1,083
Trump - 63 percent
Clinton - 55 percent
March 26-29
2,000
Trump - 62 percent
Clinton - 54 percent
March 30 - April 3
2,033
Trump - 70 percent
Clinton - 54 percent
March 31 - April 4
1,076
Trump - 69 percent
Cruz - 59 percent
April 8 - 11
2,000
Trump - 63 percent
Clinton - 56 percent
April 10 - 14
1,000
Trump - 65 percent
Clinton - 56 percent
April 17-20
1,000
Trump - 65 percent
Clinton - 56 percent
SOURCE: RealClearPolitics
The numbers show Trump all but once ranking No. 1 in unfavorable ratings.
After Cruz suspended his campaign, we reached out to share this pattern and didn’t hear back.
Our ruling
Before bowing out for president, Cruz said Trump had the second-highest disapproval ratings of anyone bidding for president.
Not quite. A February 2016 poll showed Clinton with slightly worse ratings than Trump, who had the second-worst rating overall. But the unfavorability gap between Clinton and Trump also fell within the poll’s margin of error--and more than 20 other polls taken from February into April 2016 each showed Trump at No. 1 in disapproval.
We rate this statement False.
FALSE – The statement is not accurate. Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.
https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/b4d0da45-3dc9-4b36-b329-65d85ab8b115
Our Sources
YouTube video, "War Room," Ted Cruz presidential campaign, April 21, 2016
Emails, Catherine Frazier, Cruz campaign national press secretary, May 2, 2016
Phone interview, Tim Malloy, assistant director, Quinnipiac University Polls, May 24, 2016
Poll, Quinnipiac University, conducted Feb. 10-15, 2016
Poll, Associated Press, conducted Feb. 11-15, 2016
Poll, NBC News and Wall Street Journal, conducted Feb. 14-16, 2016
Poll, The Economist and YouGov, conducted Feb. 24-27, 2016
Poll, Public Policy Polling, conducted Feb. 2-3, 2016
Poll, CNN and ORC, conducted Feb. 24-27, 2016
Poll, Gallup, conducted Feb. 26 - March 3, 2016
Poll, ABC News/The Washington Post, conducted March 3-6, 2016
Poll, The Economist and YouGov, conducted March 10-12, 2016
Poll, Monmouth University, conducted March 17-20, 2016
Poll, CNN and ORC, conducted March 17-20, 2016
Poll, CBS News and The New York Times, March 17-20
Poll, Quinnipiac Polls, conducted March 19-22, 2016
Poll, Bloomberg, conducted March 19-22, 2016
Poll, Fox News, conducted March 20-22,2016
Poll, Public Policy Polling, conducted March 24-26, 2016
Poll, The Economist and YouGov, conducted March 26-29, 2016
Poll, The Atlantic and PRRI, conducted March 30-April 3,2016
Poll, Associated Press and GfK, conducted March 31- April 4, 2016
Poll, The Economist and YouGov, conducted April 8-11, 2016
Poll, NBC News and The Wall Street Journal, conducted April 10-14, 2016
Poll, George Washington University, conducted April 17-20, 2016
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Dylan Baddour
Ted Cruz incorrectly says Donald Trump has 'second-highest disapproval' of any presidential hopeful
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.