World TB deaths shoot up -- on paper

A reader of a recent statement from the medical aid group Doctors Without Borders might be forgiven for thinking we are losing ground in the battle against tuberculosis.

"The World Health Organization’s annual look at the global state of tuberculosis this year makes for a shockingly bad report card," the statement began. It then noted "WHO’s report reveals that more people are dying of TB and more people are left undiagnosed and untreated than last year, creating a cycle of TB transmission and death."

We went to the WHO tuberculosis report to see if more people are dying of TB and if so, does that amount to shockingly bad news.

The answer is that while Doctors Without Borders has its numbers right, the increase is the result of better reporting, which people in public health, including Doctors Without Borders, see as a plus in the battle against any disease.

The WHO tuberculosis update

In 2015, WHO estimated that tuberculosis killed 1.4 million people directly and was the proximate cause of death for an additional 0.4 million people infected with HIV. Together, the death toll was 1.8 million.

In 2014, WHO estimated the total number of deaths at 1.5 million, with about 1.1 million who died exclusively from tuberculosis and another 0.4 million who were HIV-positive.

So that’s pretty clear. The total death toll rose by about 300,000.

But as the authors of the latest report spell out, the change stems from better counting, not in the growing reach of the disease.

"The TB epidemic is larger than previously estimated, reflecting new surveillance and survey data from India," the report said.

Prudence Smith, a WHO spokeswoman, explained that between 2013 and 2015, India shifted from a reporting system based on paper to one that lives on the Internet.

"In addition," Smith said, "the country has made case notification legally mandatory."

In the world of tuberculosis, India is a huge deal. It is home to more than 25 percent of all TB cases and deaths worldwide.

With better raw data in hand, the estimated death toll in India more than doubled between 2014 and 2015. While that might seem shocking, what really happened is that the earlier estimates low-balled deaths by a huge amount.

So, has the situation deteriorated?

Not really.

There are two ways to measure progress. You can estimate deaths and from that, you can estimate the TB death rate within the population. The same WHO report said both deaths and the death rate are down dramatically since 2000.

We looked at estimates from another respected source, the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of Washington. In an Oct. 8, 2016, Lancet article, the institute looked at the trend between 2005 and 2015. As you can see in this chart, the University of Washington group’s estimates mirror those of the WHO. 

Featured Fact-check

Instagram posts

stated on November 7, 2024 in Instagram posts

“2,038 suicides have been reported (Nov. 6) following Donald Trump’s election win.”

Jennifer Kates, director of global health and HIV policy at the Kaiser Family Foundation, told us the numbers can seem confusing. Kates said there’s been a strong effort to amp up the accuracy of tracking TB for some time, and she doesn’t find the latest figures surprising.

"Newer methods, better data, and so on yield better estimates and that sometimes makes understanding the trends and messaging about them much harder," Kates said.

Doctors Without Borders spokeswoman Brienne Prusak said the latest figures paint a dire picture. Prusak noted that the report shows that TB deaths topped those by HIV/AIDS.

Kates, WHO and Doctors Without Borders applaud the improved TB monitoring. They also all say that funding to combat the disease falls well short of what’s needed. The WHO said the global effort ought to be in the neighborhood of $8.3 billion. Current spending is about $2 billion shy of that.

The 2015 estimate from the WHO has a special significance. It is the starting point in a 20-year plan to not just stop tuberculosis, but to end it.

Our ruling

The group Doctors Without Borders called the latest WHO report on TB shockingly bad and noted that more people are dying from the disease. That statement about the rise in the deaths ascribed to tuberculosis is accurate. Estimated deaths rose by about 300,000 people.

But much of that increase has more to do with better reporting and more complete data than an actual increase in deaths. As the WHO report noted, experts came to believe that earlier estimates were too low. This was largely driven by the numbers out of India.

Looking back 10 years, the trends in the number of deaths and the TB death rate show steady improvement.

The statement is partially accurate but leaves out important details.

We rate this claim Half True.