Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Tale of killer whales eating Japanese whalers is fake news
A fake story being shared on social media about Japanese whalers meeting an untimely end in the bellies of a pod of orcas may sound fishy for a reason — it is.
"Japanese whaling crew eaten alive by killer whales, 16 dead," shouts a horror-show headline on a Feb. 11, 2017, post on ReligionMind.com. Facebook brought the post to our attention as potentially being fake as part of its efforts to eliminate false stories from its news feeds.
The story — which again, didn’t happen — recounts the fate of the hapless crew of the whaler MV Nisshin Maru, many of whom abandoned ship after a gas leak forced them to clear the deck.
The ship was supposedly stranded in the Southern Ocean Whale Sanctuary, off the coast of South Africa. In a twist of irony too dark to be true (because it isn’t), 16 whalers were swallowed by killer whales within a half hour of hitting the water.
The yarn cast a wide net, landing on several websites, with one version of the article posted as late as Feb. 12. But we didn’t take the bait.
Sign up for PolitiFact texts
The origin of this fish tale (yes, we know killer whales are mammals) goes all the way back to July 28, 2014. That’s when WorldNewsDailyReport.com, a website known for posting contrived stories, first published the saga of the Nisshin Maru.
The story was pretty popular back then, too, because several media outlets wrote articles to point out it was a made-up story. Nearly all of them made reference to the site’s disclaimer, which reads, "All news articles contained within worldnewsdailyreport.com are fiction, and presumably fake news."
Featured Fact-check
There’s no indication on the various posts we found identifying the story is fake. There’s also no mention that it is several years old.
We’ve noticed here at PolitiFact that some fake news stories seem to come back into the social media consciousness after a couple of years in limbo. We don’t know why this one returned to port after so long adrift, but the story is still anchored in fiction.
We rate it Pants On Fire!
https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/8ce44b69-3cfe-4eff-9f9f-0781ee391e09
Our Sources
ReligionMind.com, "Japanese whaling crew eaten alive by killer whales, 16 dead," Feb. 11, 2017
WorldNewsDailyreport.com, "Japanese whaling crew eaten alive by killer whales, 16 dead," July 28, 2014
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Joshua Gillin
Tale of killer whales eating Japanese whalers is fake news
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.