No source for supposed Pelosi statement about undocumented immigrants

The debate over immigration reform has long roiled Congress as Republicans and Democrats spar over how to secure the U.S.-Mexico border. But a May 20 Facebook post seems designed to undermine House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s authority in this particular fray.

"Just because someone is here illegally doesn’t mean they broke any of our laws," Pelosi is quoted as saying in the post. Underneath Pelosi’s photo, two Star Trek characters hold their faces in their hands in an image that seems to project weariness or frustration.

This post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)

The question of whether undocumented immigrants commit a crime by virtue of being in the country is less clear-cut than it seems: At PolitiFact, we have examined the matter before and found, actually, most of the time it is not a crime to be undocumented in the United States.

But the purpose of this fact-check is to determine whether or not Pelosi actually said what this post attributes to her.

A spokesman for Pelosi did not immediately respond to an email from PolitiFact asking if the quote is authentic.

We searched the Nexis database of English-language news for the quote and "Nancy Pelosi" and found only one result: a March 20 column in the Tri-County Times from Fenton, Mich., that espouses some popular conservative views and attributes the statement in the Facebook post to Pelosi. But the columnist doesn’t provide any context for the statement, such as when or where Pelosi said it.

Searching for the quote online we encountered similar attributions — lacking context and often suggesting Pelosi is stupid. But we couldn’t find any credible citations for the quote.

On an immigration page on her congressional website, there is no mention of crime or scofflaws. On an immigration reform page on the House speaker’s website, it says: "We will continue to work toward a comprehensive solution for our country’s broken immigration system, and we will never stop fighting to ensure that America remains a land of opportunity for those who work hard, abide by our laws and dare to dream."

Next we looked for any similar remarks Pelosi might have made.

In 2006, she said on the PBS NewsHour that not all of the millions of illegal immigrants came to the country illegally.

"Some did," she said. "Some came and their visas expired or they’re on a backlog at the immigration service, when it was called the immigration service. And so a number of reasons why people’s documents are not in order, but many did come in illegally. And that is that we do have to strengthen security at the border; there is no question about that. Everyone agrees to that."

More recently, Pelosi chastised a reporter for saying "illegal alien," RealClearPolitics reported in June 2018.

Featured Fact-check

Threads posts

stated on October 9, 2024 in a Threads post

Video shows “people attempting to flee Florida & Hurricane Milton.”

"Using terminology like ‘illegal aliens illegally entering the country’ is just not viewed as constructive," Pelosi said. "The fact is that we have — we must protect our borders; that is our responsibility. We also must protect our values; that’s our responsibility as well."

She went on to say, "what we’re talking about here, though, are asylum seekers, and that has nothing to do with illegal entry into the country."  

Snopes, which also failed to find evidence that Pelosi made the statement in the Facebook post when it fact-checked the claim in January, notes other politicians have shared a similar sentiment to the quote.

In 2016, Democratic senator and presidential candidate Kamala Harris tweeted: "An undocumented immigrant is not a criminal."

In 2008, former Republican New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, then a U.S. attorney, said that sneaking into the country may be a civil wrong but that it isn’t criminal.

"Being in this country without proper documentation is not a crime," Christie said, according to a 2008 story in the Star-Ledger. "The whole phrase ‘illegal immigrant’ connotes that the person, by just being here, is committing a crime."

The paper also quotes him as saying: "Don’t let people make you believe that that’s a crime that the U.S. Attorney’s Office should be doing something about. It’s not."

What we couldn’t find was a quote from Pelosi. If one emerges, we’ll reconsider this fact-check. For now, we rate the Facebook post False.

Share the Facts

2019-05-29 19:26:56 UTC

PolitiFact

2

1

7

PolitiFact Rating:

False

Nancy Pelosi said, "Just because someone is here illegally doesn’t mean they broke any of our laws."

Viral image

On the internet

Monday, May 20, 2019

2019-05-20

Read More

info