The testing labs used to certify Arizona’s voting equipment were accredited, officials say

Members of the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors have heard a number of baseless accusations about the Nov. 8 Arizona election.

One is that the testing laboratory that certifies voting equipment in Arizona was not accredited, invalidating the election. This claim has surfaced before — in meetings, lawsuits and on social media — and it came up again at the board’s Nov. 16 public hearing.

Video from the meeting was shared on Instagram on Nov. 23 with a headline that says the 2022 Maricopa County election has been declared "unlawful."

It shows a man speaking before the board. "The elections were unlawful," he says, "because the voting machines were not accredited in accordance with Arizona statute 16-442 bravo." he says.

The Instagram post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram.)

Though he did not expand on the accreditation claim during the meeting, he said in  a video interview captured outside the hearing that accreditation for a test lab had expired in 2018.

It’s a claim Schafer has made before, according to Arizona Public Media.

But Arizona election officials and the commission that certifies election equipment said the claim has no validity.

"The basis for this conspiracy is a misunderstanding of the federal lab testing accreditation process," said Sophia Solis, deputy communications director for the Arizona secretary of state.

Test laboratories are independent labs designed to test voting systems and software to ensure they meet federal guidelines. They must be accredited by the U.S. Election Assistance Commission, according to the Help America Vote Act, passed in 2002.

Solis said all equipment used in Arizona elections must be certified by the commission and by the Arizona secretary of state. The secretary’s certification is based on a recommendation by its Equipment Certification Advisory Committee. The goal is to ensure equipment meets federal and state requirements.

As part of that process, she said, all equipment must be tested by a voting system test laboratory that is accredited under the Help America Vote Act. That is spelled out in Arizona statute 16-442.

"All voting systems used in the 2022 election in Arizona have met these requirements," Solis said.

Arizona used voting equipment made by three different companies in the 2022 election, the secretary of state’s website says: Dominion, Election Systems & Software and Unisyn. An Election Assistance Commission website also shows all Arizona counties using equipment from those three companies that have been certified.

The commission has confirmed that both of the voting system test laboratories used in Arizona have had regular assessments during their accreditations, Solis said. The testing companies Pro V&V and SLI Compliance certified the state’s equipment.

An administrative error meant Pro V&V did not receive an updated certificate for the 2017-19 period, commission said. But that didn’t mean it was not accredited. 

"Even though the EAC failed to reissue the certificate, Pro V&V’s audit was completed in 2018 and again in early 2021," the commission wrote. The 2020 audit was postponed due to COVID-19 travel restrictions. 

"Pro V&V and SLI Compliance remained in good standing with the requirements of our program and retained their accreditation," during that time, they said.

Under federal law, a lab can’t lose accreditation unless the commission votes to revoke it. This has not happened with either company, Solis said.

Featured Fact-check

Facebook posts

stated on November 21, 2024 in Facebook posts

“Taylor Swift has moved to Canada after leaving the U.S. following the big red wave.”

Maricopa County Election Director Scott Jarrett spoke about the certification allegations in a Maricopa County Board of Supervisors public hearing Nov. 28.

"The Election Assistance Commission has said that Pro V&V, the voting system laboratory that certified the Dominion equipment and the other voting system testing laboratory, SLI Compliance … their certifications have never been revoked," he said beginning about the 3:58:20 mark of the video.

Maricopa County Elections Department spokesperson Matt Roberts said the Arizona secretary of state and Election Assistance Commission approved the Dominion voting equipment used in the county before the general election.

Roberts also said the county in 2021 initiated a "multilayered forensic audit" of its tabulation equipment. 

Pro V&V and SLI Compliance tested the election equipment hardware and software the county used in the 2020 election. Neither company found any problems with the equipment.

A certified public accounting company, BerryDunn, "reviewed county contracts with Dominion Voting Services and verified that the county leased the tabulation equipment according to state and county procurement regulations," Roberts said.

An Instagram post claimed the 2022 Arizona election was unlawful because voting equipment was improperly certified by a voting system test laboratory whose certification had expired.

Arizona election officials said that is not the case, and that all equipment used had been certified in accordance with state and federal law. The federal Election Assistance Commission said that although paperwork was not updated for Pro V&V, one of the testing labs used, in 2017-2019, the company has remained certified. 

We rate this False.

PolitiFact researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report

RELATED: Maricopa’s final election results aren’t missing thousands of votes

RELATED: Kari Lake claimed Maricopa County voters were ‘disenfranchised.’ Experts disagree.

RELATED: No, Maricopa vote tabulators didn’t lead to ballots with ‘no chain of custody’