Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Snow and a lack of wind are not stopping solar and wind energy production in Germany
If Your Time is short
-
Weather conditions can reduce the output of renewable energy sources, but neither snow nor wind significantly hampered Germany’s energy sources.
-
The claim originated in February 2021 and was previously debunked by Agence France-Presse.
A viral post from more than a year ago has been recirculating, claiming that German renewable energy isn’t working properly due to winter weather.
"In Germany, millions of solar panels are blanketed in snow and 30,000 wind turbines are sitting idle because there’s no wind," said a meme shared Sept. 25 on Instagram. It includes a photo of snow-blanketed solar panels.
The post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram.)
The claim, however, has no basis in fact. German solar panels and wind turbines were functioning normally in 2021, this claim previously circulated. And experts say winter weather hasn’t generally posed a significant threat to renewable energy.
The meme in the post cites the Australian news site SkyNews. A February 2021 segment from the SkyNews show "Outsiders," shows Australian conservative news commentator Rowan Dean stating that "millions of solar panels are blanketed in snow and 30,000 wind turbines are sitting idle because there’s no wind."
Sign up for PolitiFact texts
Dean did not elaborate about the source of his claim and he didn’t respond to PolitiFact’s request for more information.
We found the photo on the website of British stock photo agency Alamy with a caption that reads, "Solar panels are covered with snow at the solar park in Meuro, Germany, 21 February 2013. Despite covered by snow the modules produce 5 megawatts of power." According to a website that tracks energy production data, German solar and wind production experienced no significant or sudden drops during February 2021.
Experts told PolitiFact that cold weather and lack of wind can affect energy production, but the implication of a mass failure of these energy sources is wrong. "The claim that millions of PV (photovoltaic) modules don't provide electricity in winter is of course nonsense," Karsten Schafer, a spokesman for the German Solar Industry Association, told Agence France-Presse in 2021 for a fact-check about a similar meme.
Featured Fact-check
Snow buildup doesn’t cause significant issues in Germany’s ability to produce solar power, according to Ute Stewart, press and communication officer for Berlin Energy Transition Dialogue. In an email to PolitiFact, Stewart wrote that there is almost never a day when intense snowfall affects the whole country.
"If you look at the yearly yield," Stewart wrote, "the loss (of solar power) is insignificant at best, under 1%." At higher altitudes, the loss of solar power because of snowfall can be up to 6%, he wrote, but there aren’t many solar panels at higher altitudes. Some of the snowiest countries in the world use solar power.
An Instagram post says, "In Germany, millions of solar panels are blanketed in snow and 30,000 wind turbines are sitting idle because there’s no wind."
There is no data or evidence to support this claim. German solar and wind production energy production experienced no sudden drops the first time this rumor started in February 2021, nor recently.
We rate this claim False.
Our Sources
Instagram Post, Sept. 25, 2022
LeadStories, "Fact Check: Germany's Wind Turbines And Solar Panels Did NOT Suddenly Stop Working Due To Weather Conditions," Feb. 17, 2021
Reneweconomy, "Google’s Sky News Australia team-up will make it a climate misinformation powerhouse," Feb. 19, 2021
MSN, "World’s ‘solar and wind capital’ freezing due to snow ‘blanketing millions’ of solar panels," Feb. 15, 2021 (Accessed via archive Oct. 2, 2022)
AAP, "Misleading memes in the dark on renewable energy ‘fail’ during German winter," March 5, 2021
SkyNews, "World’s ‘solar and wind capital’ freezing due to snow ‘blanketing millions’ of solar panels," Feb. 14, 2021
Agence France-Presse, "German solar, wind power did not fail in cold weather," Feb. 19, 2021
Energy-charts.info, "Öffentliche Nettostromerzeugung in Deutschland 2021," accessed Oct. 10, 2022
Energy-charts.info, "Öffentliche Nettostromerzeugung in Deutschland 2022," accessed Oct. 10, 2022
British Petroleum, "Statistical Review of World Energy," accessed Oct. 10, 2022
Ember Climate, "European Electricity Review 2022," Feb. 1, 2022
Our World in Data, "Germany: Energy Country Profile," accessed Oct. 10, 2022
Wind Power Monthly, "Wind-generated electricity in Germany slumps to new low in 2021," Jan. 10, 2022
SMARD, "The electricity market in 2021," Jan. 07, 2022
SMARD, "Renewables' share of generation high," Apr. 8, 2022
International Energy Agency, "Germany's Renewables Energy Act," Dec. 7, 2021
Snow-Online, "Germany Snow Reports," accessed Oct. 3, 2022
EnergySage, "Do solar panels work in the winter? Solar snow performance explained," Jan 4, 2019
North Alberta Institute of Technology, "Results from a study led by NAIT’s Alternative Energy Technology program include good news for Canadians looking to install solar panels," July 12, 2018
E-mail interview with Ute Stewart, Berlin Energy Transition Dialogue, Oct. 7, 2022
BBC, "The world’s most unlikely solar farms," Feb. 19, 2020
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Kristin Hugo
Snow and a lack of wind are not stopping solar and wind energy production in Germany
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.