New York state’s Clean Slate law doesn’t keep convictions sealed from everyone

New York’s Clean Slate Act, intended to help convicts secure jobs and housing after they have served their sentences, has come under fire from Republicans, who call the law too friendly to criminals. 

U.S. Rep. Nick LaLota, a Republican from eastern Long Island, shared claims about the act on Facebook: "Thanks to radical Democrats, violent crimes will be hidden from public view and background checks. These crimes will now be automatically sealed after a set time— like they never happened." 

We wondered if the new law seals crimes "like they never happened." 

Gov. Kathy Hochul signed the Clean Slate Act on Nov. 16 after years of negotiation on the kinds of crimes that would be included and the terms under which they would be hidden from public view, including the length of the waiting period. 

LaLota’s office told PolitiFact that the Facebook post does not claim the records will be expunged. "By definition, sealed information will not appear in criminal background checks, except in the limited circumstances which would be crimes not covered under Clean Slate," spokesman Will Kiley said.

We found, however, that these records will be sealed for some background checks, but not others. 

The law automatically seals records of some state crimes, but few Class A felonies, such as murder or terrorism. Sex offenses and sexually violent offenses are also excluded from sealing. In general, after people are sentenced, or in cases in which they are incarcerated, after they are released, eligible records would be sealed after three years for a misdemeanor and eight years for a felony. If the waiting period is over but the convicted people are still under community supervision, the crimes are sealed when community supervision concludes. If people with convictions commit crimes during the waiting period, the clock restarts. 

The law allows convictions to be sealed — not expunged. Law enforcement officers, prosecutors and judges still have access to the records. If people reoffend, their criminal history can be taken into account in any new prosecution and sentence. 

"These records are not getting erased," said Jillian E. Snider, an adjunct lecturer at John Jay College of Criminal Justice. 

Criminal records will remain available to those conducting background checks for jobs that require fingerprinting. These include jobs working in law enforcement or with vulnerable populations, such as children, people with disabilities and older adults. Ride-share companies will also have access to them to vet contractors, as will the state Education Department. The Department of Motor Vehicles and people who process pistol permit applications will still have access to sealed convictions. 

"This is a bill about second chances and opportunities," said Ames Grawert, a lawyer with the Brennan Center for Justice, an advocate for the legislation. "It’s not a completely wipe-the-record-away sort of law. There are a number of exceptions." 

The law takes effect a year after it was signed, but it will take four years to implement, because of the complexity of automating the sealing in the state court records system, Grawert said. 

The Facebook meme lists several crimes that are eligible for sealing under the new law, including gang assault, aggravated manslaughter of a police officer, and second-degree attempted murder. The law enforcement experts we spoke with said those crimes will be sealed under the law. 

Featured Fact-check

Social Media

stated on December 9, 2024 in in social media posts

Substack article shows manifesto of Luigi Mangione, the suspect in health care executive's killing.

Recidivism data shows that if people do not reoffend after seven years, they probably won’t do so. That explains the eight-year waiting period, in which people cannot commit another crime or the clock starts over, Snider said. 

The state had a process for sealing some criminal records, but it was very difficult to access and some applications took more than a year to be processed, said Kate Wagner-Goldstein, a lawyer who advocated for the new law. 

A meme was shared on social media claiming that New York’s Clean Slate Law seals violent crimes after a set time "like they never happened." 

For people with criminal convictions who do not reoffend and have not been convicted of Class A violent felonies or sex crimes, their records will be sealed for many purposes, including securing housing or many different jobs. 

But for law enforcement officers, prosecutors, judges and those who grant gun licenses or driver’s licenses or hire people to work with vulnerable populations, those records will not be hidden from view. For them, the law will not make it like those crimes never happened. 

Because this claim has an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression, we rate this Mostly False.