Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Ciara O'Rourke
By Ciara O'Rourke October 11, 2024

Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz extended a finger at a recent college football game, but not the middle one

If Your Time is short

  • Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz pointed at the crowd at a recent college football game; he didn’t give fans "the bird."

In a viral social media post comparing the vice presidential nominees, shots are not so much fired as f-bombs are dropped. 

"Vance vs. Walz," the post begins, laying out a case that favors Sen. JD Vance, R-Ohio, the Republican nominee, over Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, the Democratic nominee. "Vance denied entry at a restaurant. He wishes them continued success and pays everyone’s tab anyway. Walz booed at the football game. He flips the crowd the bird." 

"Is this true?" one Facebook post said. It was flagged as part of Meta’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Meta, which owns Facebook, Instagram and Threads.)

The post fumbles a critical detail: Walz did not give fans the middle finger. 

Vance’s stop at Primanti Bros.

On Sept. 28, Vance visited a Primanti Bros. restaurant in North Versailles, Pennsylvania. 

Sign up for PolitiFact texts

Sean Logue, the Republican chair of Washington County, Pennsylvania, was one of about 100 supporters of former President Donald Trump who was there after being tipped off that Vance was going to visit, CBS News reported

"The manager told patrons, other Republicans, that Vance is not allowed to make a campaign stop at Primanti Brothers," Logue said. "And then when there was pushback to say, 'Wait a second, Kamala Harris just did this a month ago,' the response was, 'Well, if he wants to sit down and order food, we can't stop him.’"

When Vance arrived ahead of an event in Monroeville, Logue said that the restaurant's manager ran out to tell him that he was not allowed in the restaurant, that he couldn't have a campaign stop there, and that if he did go inside, the manager would call the police and file trespassing charges.

Logue told CBS News that a Vance staffer tried to negotiate with the Primanti manager, who called the restaurant’s corporate office, and Vance eventually walked back into the restaurant.

TribLive.com, a Pittsburgh and Western Pennsylvania news outlet, reported that Vance said the manager "just got a little nervous, but it’s a great local business" and encouraged people to "keep on supporting it." 

Vance also said: "We paid for everybody’s food, we gave them a nice tip."

Featured Fact-check

Primanti Bros. echoed this in an X post later that day: "Without any advance notice, today’s campaign stop caused some momentary confusion for our staff. However, Senator Vance and his team were welcomed into our restaurant shortly after and engaged with our guests inside and on the property. Senator Vance’s supportive comments that our manager got a little nervous given the Secret Service, police and crowd accurately reflect the nature of what occurred, and we are glad that it was resolved quickly."

Walz’s Michigan stop

The same day that Vance visited the restaurant, Walz was in Michigan to watch the University of Minnesota play the University of Michigan in football. 

Video from the game shows Walz leaving the field at Michigan Stadium, waving and at one point extending an arm and finger. In the audio that plays with the video, a man can be heard yelling, "Trump 2024, baby!" Other video footage from outside of the stadium shows people booing Walz.

The video of Walz leaving the field isn’t crisp, but he’s not flipping someone off — he’s pointing. That becomes clear when comparing the moment to an Instagram photo Walz posted Sept. 29. 

The image was taken of Walz from the front as he exited the field; he’s surrounded by the same people that appear in the video. And here he’s obviously pointing. 

We rate claims he flipped the crowd the bird False.

Our Sources

Facebook post, Oct. 6, 2024

Facebook post, Sept. 29, 2024

Tim Walz Instagram post, Sept. 29, 2024

Fox News, Fans boo Tim Walz as he leaves Michigan-Minnesota game: 'Get out of here!' Sept. 28, 2024

TribLive.com, JD Vance initially turned away from Primanti Bros. in North Versailles, Sept. 28, 2024

PennLive, Primanti Bros., JD Vance explain incident at Pa. stop as social media calls for boycott, Sept. 29, 2024

CBS News, Primanti Brothers denies claim Sen. JD Vance was "banned" from entering, Vance encourages support of small business, Sept. 29, 2024 

X post, Sept. 29, 2024

University of Michigan Athletics, Mullings, First-Half Defense Help U-M Defeat Minnesota, Retain Little Brown Jug, Sept. 28, 2024 

 

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Ciara O'Rourke

Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz extended a finger at a recent college football game, but not the middle one

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up