Florida's algae-stricken springs became a source of criticism toward Gov. Rick Scott's administration as he campaigned for a second term. Scott responded in part by touting a more environmentally friendly platform.
Scott's promised to issue an executive order that would get the restoration conversation going.
"Gov. Scott will issue an executive order to provide a foundation for bringing together stakeholders to plan with his administration for additional needed actions," Scott's "Let's Keep Florida Beautiful" proposal stated.
Scott never did issue an executive order.
His office pointed to other stuff he did, such as signing the 2016 Florida Springs and Aquifer Protection Act (SB 552), which Scott signed in January 2016. As required by the law, the Department of Environmental Protection adopted 13 Basin Management Action Plans to protect 24 identified Outstanding Florida Springs.
"These restoration plans were developed in close coordination with local governments and stakeholders, including more than 90 public meetings held within these spring areas," DEP spokeswoman Lauren Engel said.
Engel added that the 2016 Legacy Florida bill (HB 989) also involved stakeholder and public input in selecting projects to receive the recurring $50 million put toward Florida's springs.
Advocates of Florida springs have criticized both laws, however, arguing the language allows for loopholes that continue to permit pollution and that the legislation isn't being enforced.
Robert Knight, director of the Howard T. Odum Florida Springs Institute, called the Florida Springs and Aquifer Protection Act a "wolf in sheep's clothing," saying it placed springs restoration responsibility "in the hands of the same state agencies, using the same regulatory tools that have been so ineffective over the past 30 years."
"The fact is Gov. Scott's administration was pretty much a disaster for protection of springs and other natural environments in Florida," Knight told PolitiFact Florida. "The Legislature did pass the Springs and Aquifer Protection Action in 2016, but it was a smoke screen for continued non-enforcement of Florida's strong environmental regulations."
Ryan Smart, the executive director of the Florida Springs Council — a coalition of 45 springs advocacy organizations — said that losses from previous cuts to Florida's water management districts under the Scott administration "more than wipe out any gains" from the Legacy Florida Act.
Scott's springs restoration promises in his re-election campaign were a break from his early actions. In 2012, he canceled a springs restoration program started by former Gov. Jeb Bush.
There was progress on springs funding and coordination in Scott's second term, and Scott played a role by signing the bills. However, Scott didn't sign an executive order related to springs protection. We rate this Promise Broken.